PDA

View Full Version : Dork reviews Enterpise - 'Extinction', 9-24-03


vhsiv
09-26-2003, 01:14 AM
snurched from Kansas (http://forums.scaperoute.com/kansas/index.php?board=20;action=display;threadid=9969;st art=0#msg124870)

Dork: Whew. This thing took longer than expected -It took hours, I?m not kidding hours. It's way too long, I'll trim it later- This is for Lobsteronmyhead. If it weren?t for you I wouldn?t have done anything even quasi-productive today.
--------------------------
Okay, before we get going it should be noted that I don?t write particularly well under pressure. And I only wrote this one because Lobster?s looking for it. Before the episode aired I was planning on pretending Archer was our beloved BabE Mr. Garibaldi, but the episode- ?Extinction?? seems to have provided me with something far more amusing.

WARNING: to keep from ticking any one off unnecessarily it should be said that this isn?t a particularly kind review-thingy. If you absolutely love ?Enterprise?, or more precisely, Archer I?d stay away if I were you. I?m not very kind to the good captain. It?s nothing against Scott Bakula, he?s a good actor, he?s just not captain material.

S

P

O

I

L

E

R


S

P

A

C

E

This episode of Enterprise begins with it?s best teaser since the series premiere. It?s not fantastic, but closer to Trek?s average which, for enterprise is amazing progress. Remember that teaser where Mayweather?s just reading a book? If it weren?t Enterprise it would have been embarrassing, as it was it?s just sad. Yeah so, Fahrenheit 451 guys tracking down Dr. Zaius is a bit of an improvement.

Okay, brief run through of the first 5 minutes or so; The badies from Fahrenheit 451 saw Dr. Zaius on Guinan?s new talk show showing off his new book and, apparently, they weren?t too keen about it. Back on Enterprise Trip and T?Pol aren?t horny now but they understand that they might be in a few years. Couple that with character development being as rare on ?Enterprise? as replicator rations they continue with their ?therapy sessions? with the goal of killing two Archers with one transporter accid- sorry

For some bizarre reason, let?s call it ?the on set of insanity? to try to make things a little more interesting, Archer wants to stop by and have a look around on some random off limits planet. Actually, I don?t know why he wants to stop by. I have the eppy on tape, but come on, would you go back to check? In any event his proposed away team consists of The Captain, The Second in Command, The Ship?s Very Valuable Linguist, and Weapons? Officer who, for some odd reason over the past 3 seasons has gradually morphed into taking on the position of Chief of Security. But that doesn?t make it right. Years of watching Star Trek have muted my desire to throw my glass of cool, refreshing Mr. Pibb through the screen when these things happen. But it?s particularly irksome now. Where are the military guys in this episode anyway?

On Captain Archer?s away mission of illogic T?Pol staggers and through hazy eyes pulls back her sleeve to look at her skin as it shifts and morphs under the moon?s light. ?Oh, no,? she says, offering up a silent prayer to everything holy in Trek encyclopedia ?Not ?Resolutions*?, please not ?Resolutions?.?

The next thing T?Pol knows she?s waking up on the forest floor with regressed versions of Archer, Sato, and Malcom sniffing her hair and alternately hitting the top of her head with their fists.

//Play ?It?s Raining Men?,// says regressed Archer, from now on HeMan Dude68.

//What is it?// asks regressed Sato, from now on Sat-zilla.

//New I Pod// says Archer, giving T?Pol another whack over the head //It malfuncting// he grunts.

//I Pod got copyright protection, you should have buy new Creative Labs 6,000 gig Nomad Jukebox 47, has got good sound compared to other MP3 players// Sat-zilla suggests.

//No. Should got Clie palm handheld// says regressed Malcom, from now on Stinky.

HeMan Dude68 and Sat-zilla give Stinky a pitying look.

//What? It play MP3s// says Stinky defensively.

//Only with special sony Magic Gate Memory stick// says Sat-zilla.

//Even then not work all time// adds HeMan Dude68.

With just this one simple suggestion Stinky completely loses all pretence of respect within the group.

?Ow ow ow, stop! That?s not a toggle switch!? yells T?Pol.

Back on Enterprise Trip checks his watch. ?Mm-kay.? Trip leaves his post at engineering and goes up to the bridge. Straightening his shirt in a very captain-like way he sits in the Captain?s chair. Trip jabs at the comm. panel ?Trip to sickbay. Say, Doc, is this the 2nd or 3rd episode of the season??

?I?m not sure. In any case 20 replicator rations says the away mission?s been genetically altered in some way.?

?30 that they?ve been kidnapped,? says Mayweather from the helm.

?Any bets, Lt.?? Says Phlox from across the comm..
?Nah, I think I?ll sit this one out?

Back on the planet:

?. . .I could be handy mending a fuse, when your lights have gone, you can knit a sweater by the fireside. Sunday morning go for a drive. . .? T?Pol had to admit, it wasn?t dignified, but it was better than HeMan Dude68 looking for her toggle switch.

//I still say we trade her in for a Jukebox// says Sat-zilla

?. . .will you still need me, will you still feed me when I?m sixty-four . . .?

//Shut up, I like this song// says HeMan Dude68

Back on the ship a ship decloaks, or comes out of warp. You know I really don?t care.

?You have entered restricted space,? some guy from Stargate SG-1 tells Trip ?And your crew has been turned into American Idol fans?

?Yeah,? says Trip ?that sounds about right?

Back on the planet HeMan Dude68 wakes up //I had dream, wonderful dream.// he tells an eager Sat-zilla, //I kicked Captain Sheridan?s @$$ but good! And I got the cute alien girl//

T?Pol snorts, ?You wish?

//Oo! Oo!,// Archer directs this grunt towards Sat-zilla for some odd reason //We return her to Radio Shack tonight!//

//Oo! Oo!// Sat-zilla agrees, //then we get Jukebox!//

//Oo! Oo!//

T?Pol rolls her eyes ?I?m in hell?

In sickbay the Stargate man has just finished explaining the virus. Stinky, who the crew managed to capture while Sat-zilla and HeMan Dude68 weren?t looking is in decon.

?Let me see if I understand this. This species,? he says giving the barrier between sickbay and decon and thump ?lost the ability to breed from watching too much American Idol and so created a virus that would help them replenish the audience.?

Phlox coughed, but it sounded strikingly like he?d said ?Favorite Son?.

?Yes? the Stargate man says.

Trip gives the barrier another whack, inside Stinky has found a screw and is shoving it up his nose. ?This species.?

?It might have been their gods.? Offers Stargate man.

?Who are. . .?

?Studio heads?

Trip looks confused for a moment, then gets a look of revelation on his face ?You know what, doc that would explain a lot about this sho- ow!? Right at that moment one of Phlox?s creatures escaped and bit off a piece of his ear.

?The gods are vengeful? says Stargate man solemnly as Trip and Phlox try to keep him from bleeding on the carpet.

Back on the planet.

?Bum bum bum bum Mr. Sandman bring me a dream. . .?

//She?s broken!// screeches Sat-zilla, //she only plays oldies!//

//play ?Drrty?!// yells HeMan Dude68

//I saw sign earlier. Said Radio Shack//

?I?m telling you, there is no Radio Shack on this planet.?

Back on the ship: ?Mmm,? says one of the commandos watching ?Thank God it?s Friday. . .Again? ?Dominar Rygel, you can dominate my people anytime you like, oh yeah?

Uh, . . . anywho. . . huh, . . . tah, okay, hm, well we know where the commandos are, okay, moving right along. . .

Back on the bridge Trip?s doing some grade A panicking ?What if Archer usurps my love interest?! I?m too cute and country to be single!?

Phlox gives trip a look, ?Usurp??

?Just because I?m a country Trek character doesn?t mean I?m stupid.?

Back on the planet T?Pol is absolutely stunned, when upon turning a corner there is a Radio Shack in the middle of the forest.

HeMan Dude68 vainly pulls at the locked door. //No. . .no//

//they close// says Sat-zilla //they close//

T?Pol was seriously considering trying to get out of her 6 year contract.

From a little sign posted by the door HeMan Dude68 reads //store hour 9am to 10pm nooo, it 10:15, it 10:15// HeMan Dude68 desperately pathetically yanked at the door handle.

Right then to T?Pol?s infinite relief three guys from Enterprise materialized next to them ?Time to wrap it up. Audience attention span?s starting to wan,? one of them said

?Starting!?? cried T?Pol

?Ah, come on, T?Pol. Trying to save face here.?

?Starting!??

Finally everyone gets back on the ship, but the Stargate guy wants to kill them. But just before he does Archer walks unto the bridge //We cure virus good!// ?Uh, I mean, I?ve, like cured the virus and stuff.? The Stargate guy really just wanted to get some target practice in but it?s past Stargate guy?s bedtime so he leaves them alone.

Phlox tells Archer that he?s going to destroy the virus but Archer doesn?t want to destroy the virus, he wants to hang on to it as a secret weapon in case the Xindi can?t be made to see reaso- no, no, no, wait. That?s not what happened. Sorry, Dork seems to have slipped into one of her many happy places Bruce Boxleitner had been cast as Archer. ::stares off into space:: oh, sorry, I was just thinking about how he works his jaw muscles just before he belts someone. Mmm, good, lord that is hot. Come all, join Dork in her happy place #23.

*Resolutions - 2nd season VOY ep. Janeway and Chakotay are bitten by a bug and spend the next three months on a planet named New Earth alone, all alone with nothing but Chakotay?s unrequited love to keep them company.

- Dork
________
Zoloft pregnancy (http://www.classactionsettlements.org/lawsuit/zoloft/)

Frellster
09-27-2003, 02:49 AM
They went down to the planet because a Xindi shuttle had crashed there and they're still tracking the Xindi. (as far i as I recall)


Who the hell is Bruce Boxlietener and why the hell would you want him playing Archer?

Wait a sec, since this is snurched, the poster isn't the poster, so scratch any sort of question.

shamecube
09-27-2003, 08:07 PM
“Just because I’m a country Trek character doesn’t mean I’m stupid.”

No, it just means you're inbred

LOL, this was very, very funny. I fell asleep halfway through this episode. I swear this show make my eyelids so heavy.

Are there more on Kansas?

vhsiv
09-28-2003, 12:00 AM
Frellster: Actually, Dork *is* a member of this board, but she usually posts her stuff over at Kansas - last week I encouraged her to cross-post her review of 'Anomaly' here, this week I just went ahead and did it for her. If you want to wring some explications out of her, just look up her member name, and PM her.

But I can tell you, Bruce Boxleitner played Sheridan, the Captain, on Babylon 5 - and he's also the real-life husband of SAG president Melissa Gilbert.

shamecube: Yes, there's another review on this board, search for 'Dork reviews Enterprise' both here and on Kansas. It's actually starting to be a weekly event, though I'm pretty sure she didn't start posting them until after the season premiere. Another good place to look for 'Enterprise' reviews is http://www.firsttvdrama.com - the reviews certainly aren't as fun as Dork's, but they are more comprehensive - they're a blow-by-blow study in B&B's destruction of the Trek franchise - not as snarky as Television Without Pity (http://www.TelevisionWithoutPity.com), but he gets the job done.
________
Cheap Box Vaporizer (http://vaporizer.org)

shamecube
09-28-2003, 09:18 AM
but I like *snarky* so much:)

vhsiv
09-28-2003, 09:45 AM
http://forums.televisionwithoutpity.com/index.php?showtopic=3111833&st=75#
zotofmu:Nice to see that Gigi Edgley is getting work as a consultant on How To Move Like An Alien. Seriously, did those three study tapes of Chiana?Damn! I knew I'd seen Linda Park's body language before, but I couldn't put my finger on it.It also would've been funny if they had [Archer] come onto the bridge with a normal face and his Angel-in-18th-century-flashbacks hair.Heh. Perhaps they're saving the Quantum Mullet for November sweeps.

For some odd reason, I was actually half interested in this episode. Maybe it was because Hoshi actually got to do something. Maybe it was because Trip had a commanding prescence onscreen. Maybe it was because I'd seen the plot 5 times already, and I wanted to see how Enterprise would screw it up. <shrug>

I enjoyed Scratch'n'Sniff![Archer]'s acting alot more than what we've been given in prior episodes. Which makes me sad.

Somebody please point out the logic in being able to see T'Pol's hipbones creeping out above her jammie bottoms.

What exactly is the point of burning the bodies of infected people on a planet that's already apparently saturated with the virus?
________
150 (http://www.chevy-wiki.com/wiki/Chevrolet_150)

shamecube
09-28-2003, 10:31 AM
Personally, Hoshi had never looked better than she did in that episode.

What I didn't understand is Geordi LaForge in a Flash Gordon outfit coming in like Gangbusters. Would you come on an infected ship? Even if a species (with clearly inferior technology) said they had it covered?

And the silliness of the virus itself. Explain to me how a species that lost the ability to reproduce, could re-build Rome (in a day no less) and engineer a virus to turn people into lizard-thangs but not figure out how to clone shit. I mean, come on man. Oh, maybe their DNA couldn't be cloned. Dangit, thought I found a plot hole. Still, there's this thing called Natural Selection and...maybe there's a reason that things can't reproduce because THEY'RE NOT SUPPOSED TO! It's like these women who can't have kids who take all these drugs and move Heaven and Hell to have a baby and they end up having a litter. God has the most wonderful sense of humor. "You want kids so bad? Try this!" I can't have kids and I've just resigned myself to that fact.

Again, I found myself rooting for the bad guys. I think I said "Here's a perfect chance to kill three of the most annoying characters on television since Skreech."

vhsiv
09-28-2003, 10:51 AM
Originally posted by shamecube

What I didn't understand is Geordi LaForge in a Flash Gordon outfit coming in like Gangbusters. Would you come on an infected ship? Even if a species (with clearly inferior technology) said they had it covered? Funny that you say that, shamecube - because Geordi LaForge directed that episode! Yes, LeVar Burton joins the directing ranks, as have Roxanne Dawson and Cmdr. Ryker before him...

Anyway, I've found yet another source for weekly 'Enterprise' reviews, and though the site design looks UGO-ish, the writer is *no* fawning TrekWeb wannabe - see Jammer's Reviews (http://www.st-hypertext.com/index.shtml). He starts his review of 'Extinction' (http://www.st-hypertext.com/ent-3/extinction.html) thusly:When Archer, Reed, and Sato get transformed into savages and start jumping around like the guys from the Tim Burton version of Planet of the Apes, there's only one course of action: Remind yourself that at least a new Law & Order will be on later tonight.
________
Volcano Vaporizers (http://volcanovaporizer.net/)

shamecube
09-28-2003, 10:59 AM
vhsiv,

You are aware that you know more about these episodes than is generally considered healthy:)

I forgot about the Alien Sex Slave next week. Seems like the writers have been watching old eps of G.L.O.W

Selena
09-28-2003, 11:54 AM
I suspect they've been interested in anything that drew a higher than 1.5 rating anywhere ... their show is dying, they're trying desperately to revive it by any means necessary ... even if it means resurrecting plots and ideas from successful old shows.

Heck, why should skiffy be the only ones that are into reprising old shows? With Enterprise, B & B could just reprise the scripts from other successful shows and rewrite the lines for their characters. I wouldn't be at all surprised to see a Farscapian episode before long.

...as Chrichton said in Look at the Princess
"Works for me, works for the both of us!".

vhsiv
09-28-2003, 01:15 PM
Originally posted by shamecube
vhsiv,

You are aware that you know more about these episodes than is generally considered healthy:)
My day job is boring, and I gave up on politics. Besides, one of the reviewers mentioned that LeVar had directed it in the first line of his review...

Hey, what's 'G.L.O.W'?
________
Essential Vaaapp (http://essentialvaaappvaporizer.com)

LiLOrion
09-28-2003, 01:42 PM
If its the "GLOW" I'm remembering it was the "Gorgeous Ladies of Wrestling" and I wont say anymore about THAT subject, I'm ashamed to have even remembered that much. :)

vhsiv
09-28-2003, 04:30 PM
word-up, LiLOrion
If its the "GLOW" I'm remembering it was the "Gorgeous Ladies of Wrestling" and I wont say anymore about THAT subject, I'm ashamed to have even remembered that much.Ok, then - I understand. And thereby, it ought to be you shamecube that gets elected to the 'Enterprise'-Trainspotting Hall-of-Fame, since you not only came up with the G.L.O.W. reference, but had advance-recollection of T'Pol's cat-fight this coming week, when she and this Raijin slave-girl chick duke it out, I presume, over 'Pan-Fried Catfish' Tucker.
________
Medical marawana dispencery (http://dispensaries.org)

Frag_You!
09-29-2003, 11:32 PM
Gee, so exciting:

Next week we get a "sexy slave girl" that apparently is going to give the crew some trouble, as always.

...is it bad that I'm getting 'Twice Shy' vibes here? I feel like they're gonna beat that plot idea like a dead horse with a sack of glue, then sniff the glue. :smokin:

Ah, lordy. Someone just get rid of B&B already, this show is just pathetic nowadays. You'd think the lawsuits against 'em for ruining Star Trek's viability would have told the suits to do it already, but...se la vie (or however you spell it, darned french. Knew I should'a studied that when I was younger. :P)

My two cents, as always.
-Frag