PDA

View Full Version : Children's tears at 'end of the world' spoof


grinner
11-20-2004, 08:07 AM
Children's tears at 'end of the world' spoof
Deborah Haile
SPOOF: The end is nigh! Graphic: Nicola Cross

PUPILS at a Manchester school were left terrified after a teacher told them the end of the world was just days away.

During a morning assembly at St Matthew's RC High School, Moston, the head of year told youngsters that a giant asteroid was on a collision course with the Earth.

She is reported to have told the 13-year-olds that they would be allowed to leave school early so they could say their "final farewells" to their families.

The spoof story was designed to teach youngsters to live each day to the full. But a number of youngsters in the assembly believed the doomsday scenario and became upset - some reportedly burst into tears.

Officials at the school say that as soon as it became clear that some of the youngsters were anxious, the teacher made it clear that the tale was untrue.

After the assembly she visited each class to stress that the story had been made-up.

But the school has received a number of complaints from parents.

Commenting on the incident, headteacher Keith Hogan said: "The assembly was led by the head of year and its theme was `living each day to the full'.

Fictional

"To illustrate the point, the children were told a story suggesting that an asteroid was going to hit the the Earth.

"Unfortunately, a small number of pupils took the story literally and became anxious. As this became apparent, the head of year made it abundantly clear that the story was fictional and had been used to emphasise the theme of the assembly.

"Following the assembly, the head of year visited every year-9 class and again told students that the story was untrue and made every effort to ensure that those students who had been anxious were reassured."

Mr Hogan stressed that he had full confidence in the actions taken by the member of staff. "Obviously, I regret the fact that any student was distressed by the content and delivery of the assembly," he said.

"However, I am confident that the head of year acted appropriately and professionally in dealing with the incident."

Manchester councillor Alison Firth, Lib-Dem spokesman for education, believes the head of year went too far.

"This just seems to be over the top," said Coun Firth.

"These young people clearly didn't get the bigger picture, but focussed on the meteorite wiping out their families. You would expect many of them to be upset and to be crying and worried. I think this was an assembly too far."link (http://www.manchesteronline.co.uk/news/education/s/137/137526_childrens_tears_at_end_of_the_world_spoof.h tml)
Makes you realize how powerful the original 'War of the Worlds' was...

who45
11-20-2004, 08:25 AM
This teacher must not know childern very well...sheesh how did she think they would act. :g2f:

soyarma
11-20-2004, 10:03 AM
Indeed, I can't imagine that that scenario would end well.

BaseLine
11-20-2004, 10:08 AM
Good intention, bad practice.

AgentSun
11-20-2004, 10:10 AM
they're kids for crying out loud! you can't expect them to not believe something like this. and what an idiotic way of explaining things like this to kids! how are kids going to extrapolate "live life to the fullest" from "you're going to die tomorrow"....it's like having a fake hostage situation.

scrape_medic
11-20-2004, 10:34 AM
This teacher must not know childern very well...sheesh how did she think they would act. :g2f:Knowing Moston....probably gone out and shot up a few people..:g2f:

Actually that's Mosside.....

Hmmmmm wonders what Moston is like
:think:

eta_carinae
11-20-2004, 12:57 PM
Hmmm. 13 year olds? Not exactly kids, but perhaps they should have thought their delivery though a little better.

BrowderChick
11-20-2004, 01:08 PM
You have got to be kidding. :g2f: These are kids. This is not the way to go about doing something like that. :g2f:

TheBladeRoden
11-20-2004, 02:44 PM
FOr a second I thought you were talking about this

http://www.ebaumsworld.com/endofworld.html

trubador
11-20-2004, 11:54 PM
Well, if this was the TLC Network, her name would be Hildi and she'd glue feathers on the walls of the classroom. :yes:

Col.Batguano
11-21-2004, 02:13 AM
when I was about 13 my Junior Highschool did a day of education on Nuclear War awareness.
they played the Day After and Soylent Green, as educational movies.
messed with a lot of children’s minds, including myself.
a lot of kids took it as fact, that it was going to happen.
at that age I was graduating from Charlie Brown and Whinny the Poo, to Speed Racer and Battle of the Planets.
what the Hell goes through the heads of some Adults.
if you want children to appreciate living each day to the fullest take them on a field trip to the beach, or flying kites, or some other form of outdoor fun, and stop making them feel helpless and inept because they weren't born with all the answers to everything all ready installed at birth.

skyboy87
11-21-2004, 04:58 AM
Good googedy boogedy. Some grown ups will never learn!! Makes you wonder if when that teacher was young he (she?) was the one kid in class (and every class had one) that dove under the desk every time someone dropped a book on the floor!! You know, the kid who had the "Be prepared for Nuclear Attack" pamphlet in thier back pack and went around telling evey other kid not to play in the dirt, it was "dangerous".

Us relics of the cold war need to just get over it. THE BOMB is everywhere now, and if some lunatic decides to let one loose, ain't didly doo dah you can do about it. Same goes for meteors and comets. There are literally millions of them up there, and one day, maybe tomorrow, maybe a million years from now, one is going to hit us.

If you want to teach the crumb snatchin' rug rats to live life to its fullest, teach them to take a deep breath when they first walk out the door on an icy winter morning. Teach them to love thier family, even if they don't always like them. Teach them that EVERYONE has a place somewhere on this lil' blue ball floating in space. Teach them that just because things don't go your way today, doesn't mean that they won't tomorrow.

WHEW! I'm done spewing now. And.....HEY!! Lookout for that meteor!!! AAAAHhhhhh!!!

grinner
11-21-2004, 08:31 AM
They played "Soylent Green" as fact? As an example of what was going to happen? What the hell were they thinking? As good as the book is, and as good as the short story that inspired it is... it is social commentary... not something to be used as fact.

who45
11-21-2004, 09:13 AM
If you want to teach the crumb snatchin' rug rats to live life to its fullest, teach them to take a deep breath when they first walk out the door on an icy winter morning. Teach them to love thier family, even if they don't always like them. Teach them that EVERYONE has a place somewhere on this lil' blue ball floating in space. Teach them that just because things don't go your way today, doesn't mean that they won't tomorrow.

:aok:

Col.Batguano
11-21-2004, 01:31 PM
They played "Soylent Green" as fact? As an example of what was going to happen? What the hell were they thinking? As good as the book is, and as good as the short story that inspired it is... it is social commentary... not something to be used as fact.

I don't know what they where thinking or what the intention was, but the kids in my school took it as fact.
I think the teachers where full of big feelings and good intentions, and really didn't know what they where doing.

AgentSun
11-21-2004, 06:36 PM
skyboy87, where do you live? i live in No. VA too...sort of. i'm far away right now.

eta_carinae
11-21-2004, 07:48 PM
I kind of wonder if people that age can truly understand what that lesson was trying to teach. 13 is kind of the beginning of those torturous teenage years, where you are supposed to "grow up", but I don't feel like I really began to see the world past my doorstep until I was 19 or 20 (which, granted, wasn't that long ago), much less appreciate it.

This story kind of reminded me of this time when I was a kid (like 8 or 9) and we were at Disneyland. We went on this ride where you were supposed to be on a spaceship, and they showed the earth getting smaller and smaller and I was convinced we were really leaving the planet and I started to cry. Even though I knew we were at an amusement park and we were on a ride.